Sonnet eGFX Breakaway Box, First Take: A GPU upgrade path for your Mac
Apple's World Wide Developer Conference was unusually bountiful this year, offering an assortment of hardware and software updates, as well as previews of forthcoming products such as the HomePod smart speaker and iMac Pro. Somewhat overlooked was the announcement that Metal 2 -- Apple's updated graphics API, due to appear with macOS High Sierra (10.13) later this year -- would support the use of external graphics cards via a Thunderbolt 3 interface.
Macs are often criticized for their poor upgradeability, so this announcement could will be welcomed by the company's professional customers. Sonnet Technologies isn't the first company to provide an external GPU that can connect to a Mac or PC via Thunderbolt 3 -- companies such as Akitio and Mantiz offer similar upgrade options. However, Sonnet does have a long history of producing upgrade products for the Mac, and its new eGFX Breakaway Box is being used as part of Apple's developer kit for macOS High Sierra, so we were keen to explore the performance improvements that will be available to professional Mac users in the very near future.Images: Sonnet Technologies
Comprehensive benchmarking isn't really possible at the moment, as the public beta of High Sierra currently only supports the AMD Radeon RX580 as an external GPU, and with a number of limitations, such as the need to connect the eGFX to a second display when using a MacBook Pro (as we did during our tests).
Even, so the results offer some welcome good news for Apple's professional users. It is possible to use nVidia graphics cards with the Breakaway Box, using nVidia's own beta drivers, but that requires some extra hacking, so we stuck with an officially supported Asus RoG Strix RX580 provided by AMD, which costs around £390 (inc. VAT; £325 ex. VAT, or $450).
We tested a Breakaway Box with a 350W power supply, which costs £318 (inc. VAT; £265 ex. VAT, or $299), but there's also a 550W model available for £348 (inc. VAT; £290 ex. VAT, or $349) that can provide extra power to charge a laptop via the Thunderbolt interface. It's a fairly straightforward black metal enclosure, measuring a bulky 205mm high by 185mm wide by 340mm deep, but even then we had to be quite careful squeezing the full-length Radeon card through the side panel and into the single PCI-Express slot housed inside the box.Image: Sonnet Technologies Image: Cliff Joseph/ZDNet
Our 15-inch MacBook Pro recognized the external GPU automatically although, as mentioned, the High Sierra beta currently requires an external display to be connected to the Breakaway Box. This work-in progress arrangement confused our normal Cinebench R15 test software, which resolutely ignored the external GPU for some reason. However, other benchmark apps, such as Geekbench 4.1 and Unigine Heaven were able to switch between GPUs simply by dragging the app's open window from the MacBook's built-in display to our external LG monitor.Image: Cliff Joseph/ZDNet
Top ZDNET Reviews
Geekbench 4.1 reported a score of 23,640 using Apple's Metal API on the MacBook's internal AMD Radeon Pro 560, while the RX580 in the Breakaway Box delivered a roughly 30 percent performance increase to 30,600. However, OpenGL performance in Unigine Heaven provided a more substantial increase. Using Heaven's highest 'Ultra' quality setting at 1920-by-1080 (full HD) resolution, the MacBook Pro's native GPU managed a mere 16fps, but almost doubled this to 31fps when using the Breakaway Box.
Sonnet claims to have achieved frame rates around 55fps using nVidia's GeForce GTX 1060 cards, so professional Mac users can certainly look forward to significant performance improvements once High Sierra get its final release.
Of course, the Breakaway Box does add some £300 to the basic cost of whatever graphics card you choose, but using an external enclosure has other advantages too. It can easily be shared by several users in an office -- who can then argue over whose deadline is most important. The Breakaway Box isn't limited to just GPUs either, as you could swap in alternatives, such as high-end audio cards, which could be useful for small studios needing to work with a range of multimedia applications.
Sonnet has also indicated that High Sierra will allow the Breakaway Box to work with older Macs featuring Thunderbolt 2, with only a minor performance penalty. That would certainly be an enticing and cost-effective option for existing Mac users -- although it is, of course, subject to confirmation with the final release of High Sierra.
ConclusionsImage: Sonnet Technologies
If nothing else, the arrival of macOS High Sierra will be welcomed by Apple's professional users if it finally allows them to make use of graphics upgrades such as Sonnet's eGFX Breakaway Box. Even using the beta OS and currently available drivers, the Breakaway Box delivers significant performance improvements for Apple's current professional Mac models. It's not cheap, but it's still far cheaper than buying a brand-new Mac -- which has been Apple's only upgrade path since the company discontinued its old Power Mac tower systems way back in 2006.
Read more reviews